theboyfromnc:

I cut apart the duet tracks in The Last Five Years so I could have a truly chronological playlist.

Suggested order:

1. Goodbye Until Tomorrow
2. Shiksa Goddess
3. I Can Do Better Than That
4. Moving Too Fast
5. Climbing Uphill
6. The Schmuel Song
7. When You Come Home To Me
8. The Next Ten Minutes
9. A Miracle Would Happen
10. A Summer In Ohio
11. A Miracle Would Happen (Reprise)
12. A Part of That
13. If I Didn’t Believe in You
14. Nobody Needs To Know
15. See I’m Smiling
16. I Could Never Rescue You/Goodbye Until Tomorrow (Reprise)
17. Still Hurting

Some of this is subjective, but I’ll gladly give my reasoning behind my choices if asked.

I couldn’t split up the end of I Could Never Rescue You/Goodbye Until Tomorrow, so Cathy still comes in for her last chorus. And The Next Ten Minutes is kinda butchered at the end, due to Cathy’s half of the conversation being moved to the beginning (I didn’t want it to play twice).

Credit for the excellent edit of the beginning portion of The Next Ten Minutes goes to bloodyorlesians because I’m not savvy enough to do it myself